Videos    Book Store   Find Contractors     Compare Quotes

Compare Proposals
 

The question

I have a 4 level split.  The 3 bedrooms, and 2 full baths on are on the 3rd level.

The 2nd full bath is off the master bedroom, but it is small. It only has a shower stall, no tub.

I want a bigger master bath with separate tub and shower stall, and 2 sinks. 

I see two possibilities: 

1) The current master bedroom is at the back of the house, over the 2 car garage.  But the garage extends out even further.

SO we could extend the master bedroom over the garage, making it larger and adding a new master bath.

We could always turn the old bath into a closetJ.

2) The 4th level is one large room converted from an attic.  (It is over the living room, dining room and kitchen).

It has slopped ceilings on each side, and is only 7ft high at the center.

We could add a dormer off the back or front of this room with a bathroom and maybe even walk-in closet.

Then use this space as our new master bedroom/bath suite.

Any thoughts on which of these is cheaper and/or easier?

FYI, we will hire contractors to do the work.

I have attached a few pictures.

 

Thanks

Jennifer

My Reply

Jennifer,
First a little lecture :). Don't build anything because it is easier or cheaper. Build it only when you are sure it will satisfy your needs. The cost or difficulty will long be forgotten but the dissatisfaction & disappointment of not getting exactly what you want will linger on forever. End of lecture.
 
The office room over the kitchen, dining room is a plus value on the house & should stay. I suspect you finished this area yourself because 7' ceilings are not permitted in most areas. I suggest you leave it as is & enjoy the use & value of the added space.
 
The way to go is to extend over the garage area. Not because it will be easier or cheaper (it is both) but because it will give you the larger bath you want & blend into what you already have.
 
Try to make a simple sketch of what you want. Then add as much detail as you can, window(s), vanity, faucets, ceramic tile etc. Call in a general contractor & ask him to improve on the sketch & detail you show him. Do this with three contractors. Make your choice of contractor. Done.
 
If you plan to contract out the work piecemeal to each contractor , carpenters, electrician, tile man, plumber etc then take a look at my do-it-yourself book. It will help a bunch.
 
Hope this all helps.
 
Regards,
Bill Harbrecht 
• Home Additions
• Dormers
◦  Dormer Addition E-Book
◦  Dormer Photos
◦  Dormer Cost
◦  Dormer Plans
◦  Dormer Construction
• First Floor Additions
• Second Story Addition
• Garage Conversion
• Room Over Garage Home Addition
• Split Level Additions
• Hi-Ranch Addition
• Inlaw Apartment Addition
• Basement Remodeling
• Garage Addition
• DIY Additions
• DIY Garage Conversions
• DIY Bathroom Remodel
• DIY Kitchen Remodel
• Room Expansion
• Testimonials
• Lower Cost Remodeling
• Remodeling Cost
• Compare Proposals
• Remodeling Contractors
• Choosing Contractors
• Designing Remodels
• Roof Design
◦  Shed Roof Photo
◦  Gable Roof photo
◦  Hip Roof photo
◦  Gambrel roof photo
◦  Mansard roof photo
• Remodeling Plans
• Remodeling Ideas
◦  Your Budget and your Wants
◦  Money or Comfort
◦  Choices and Options
◦  Getting Bids
◦  Too Soon Old
• Home Remodeling Videos
• Home Addition Articles
• Window Replacement
◦  Replacement Window Materials
◦  Replacement Windows
• Remodeling Blog
◦  Get Organized
◦  Population of Twelve
◦  Too Soon old
◦  Highballs-Lowballs
◦  Inviting the Fox
◦  Move or Improve
◦  Thanks Ryan
◦  All About Money
◦  Wives Only
◦  Not a Magician
• Read My Mail
◦  Add larger bath
◦  Add to Hi Ranch
◦  Design Fees
◦  Telephone Estimates
◦  Tax Implications
◦  Right Price
◦  Craw lSpace
◦  Estimate or Contract
◦  Dormer or first floor
◦  Second Story Modular
◦  Shell Dormers
◦  Pikes Peak
◦  Price PSF
◦  DIY or Contractor
◦  Options
◦  Invest
◦  Remodeling Worthwhile
◦  Buy Hi-Ranch?
◦  Best Dormer Questions
• Interior Doors
• Exterior Doors
• Ceramic Tile Tips
• Closet Tips
• Kitchen Cabinets Online
• Estimating
• Financing
• Celing Tips
• Cement
• Windows
• Electric
• Fireplaces
• Siding
• Walls
• Ventilation
• Insulation
• Lighting
• Patios
• Stairs
• Plumbing Fixtures
• Basement Waterproofing
• Contact
• About
• GoogleSitemap
• sitemap-alphabetical